Editor’s Page

By Guest Editorial by Fred Mittag

America’s Scary Flirtation with Trump


donald trump cartoon

Fascism, thanks to Adolf Hitler, is a word one must use with care. The scale of horror that Hitler brought to the world in the name of an ideology has become indelible history. Still, the fascist movement pursued by Mussolini, Generalíssimo Francisco Franco, Hitler, and others, had identifiable characteristics in its formative stages, on a continuum to calamity.

A dictionary definition is “a system of government that exercises a dictatorship of the extreme right, typically through the merging of state and business leadership, together with belligerent nationalism. Donald Trump flaunts enough of these characteristics to alarm responsible people. They include the German news magazine Der Spiegel, actor George Clooney, former Labor Secretary Robert Reich, the Bush family, Mitt Romney, Ann Frank’s step-sister, ex-President Vicente Fox, and the current president of Mexico, Enrique Peña Nieto.

Trump is focusing his campaign on the anger of white working people who have been losing economic ground for decades, and who are easy prey for demagogues seeking to build their power by scapegoating others. Trump has several times tweeted quotes from Mussolini, and when questioned about it, dismissed the quotes as being “inadvertent.” The question is “How can a fascist Mussolini quote be inadvertent?” He had to first find those quotes and then make the decision to use them.

In the 20s and 30s, military defeat and economic depression plagued Germany. In America, we had the crisis of 2008. There has been some recovery, but all the gains have gone to the upper .01%, basically, a handful of extremely wealthy American families. There is the problem of student debt from college loans. American workers have lost $5,000 a year in purchasing power in the last couple of decades. Although we’re not in the same economic depression that Germany was suffering after WWI, Americans are suffering from failed expectations. The 50s and 60s saw a prosperous middle class, and people expected even better for the next generation. It didn’t happen and Trump exploits this and promises to be the strong man to correct stagnant wages by putting big tariffs on outsourced production in places like Mexico and China.

Trump’s constant theme is that we’re in decline and the world is laughing at us, but he’s going to make America great again and force Mexico and China to the will of the United States. It sounds a lot like Deutschland Über Alles. A chilling sight is when Trump asks his supporters to raise their arms and pledge that they will vote for him, no matter what. It looks eerily like the Sieg heil salute at one of Hitler’s rallies.

A characteristic of fascism is that the leader does not depend on a political party, but instead, the leader appeals directly to the people. That’s what both Mussolini and Hitler did. And that’s what Donald Trump has done. For him, the Republican Party is not even relevant. He’s not part of the Republican establishment, but he’s taking over the Republican Party, just like Hitler took over German political institutions.

Fascism depends on scape-goating. For Hitler, it was the Communists, Jews, Slavs, and others. There was the nationalistic focus on purity of race. Donald Trump is using Mexicans, Muslims, and even blacks. When blacks have held protest signs at Trump rallies (Black Lives Matter), they have been roughed up and Trump approved, even saying, “Don’t worry about it. I’ll pay your legal bills.” When white nationalists such as David Duke have endorsed Trump, he was careful not to offend such support, and claimed he had never heard of David Duke, the famous Klansman and Neo-Nazi. Jews, including a the New York Times, report receiving anti-Semitic messages from Trump supporters.

Robert Paxton is a professor who has specialized in the study of fascism. He said, “I think that Donald Trump shows a rather alarming willingness to use fascist themes and fascist styles – and the response this gets, the positive response, is alarming.” Fascism rests not on any truth of doctrine. Facts don’t matter, only that the leader will actually get things done. Trump promises over and over, “Trust me. I will make America great again.” The fascists created cults of personality that assumed the appearance of strength and confidence. Trump tells his followers not to worry. “If you get laid off, I’ll get you a new job. Don’t worry about it.”

Fascists, being so nationalistic, didn’t bother about international law. Nor does Trump. He advocates torture and killing innocent family members of terrorists, against both international and American law. Donald Trump presents a profound danger to the future of America and the world.


Pin It


#2 Marcel Woland 2016-11-04 20:23
A few more thoughts on Fascism prompted by the richness of the editorial.

I looked up 'Fascism' and 'Paxton', on Wiki admittedly, and found quite a thicket of confusion. This stood out:

"The first truth is that the liberty of a democracy is not safe if the people tolerate the growth of private power to a point where it becomes stronger than their democratic state itself. That, in its essence, is fascism — ownership of government by an individual, by a group, or by any other controlling private power"
-Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

It seems to me like the problem lies not in an individual like Trump or Hitler, or even Hillary, but in the long-standing collusion, subversion, and betrayal by both parties in the US which has made 'everything old, new again'. It was Clinton the Democrat who repealed the Glass-Steagall Act and Bush the Republican who then ramped up the militarism, nationalism and corporatism even further. All the ways in which this is so lie beyond a reply to the article but they are self-evident and readily supportable.

Many years ago, my colleague at a low level job in a library who was a 'draft resister' wrote the following on a napkin when he was moving on, to better things I hope.

"Fascism = militarism + racism + nationalism + corporatism."

This simple formula does not necessarily define how one 'gets there'. But it defines the 'steady state' of Fascism once it is attained. Maybe the journey and the arrival are one.

Whether it is Hillary's face or Trump's that looms over the edifice, the state of the US is almost perfectly Fascist already.
#1 Marcel Woland 2016-11-04 19:15
The fact that the US may resemble Weimar Germany is no more Hitler's fault than it is Trump's. That 'Beast' has been generations in the making. The Clinton money-launderin g and bribe-clearing 'Foundation' and its several offshoots are a different story.

More importantly, to anyone who is even slightly apart from the fray of US 'elections' it is clear that they are now little more than a 'focus-group' (Bush the Second's term for the millions who marched in the US against the Iraq war) or a pressure relief valve to be used at will by the several Dynastic entities which contend for hegemony, both globally, and within the USA.

The only good news for the electorate, and the world, is that the USA seems to now be at war, not only with the world, but also with itself.

Add comment

Security code

 Find us on Facebook